Difference between revisions of "Wakefield, Hayes, Durkin, and Borland (2013)"

From Harridanic
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 4: Line 4:
 
Clearly, the implication that everyone who thinks about quitting, [[Stated preferences do not align with revealed preferences|actually does]], is nonsense.
 
Clearly, the implication that everyone who thinks about quitting, [[Stated preferences do not align with revealed preferences|actually does]], is nonsense.
  
The fact that these numbers equate to
+
The fact that these numbers equate to a nigh-on 10% difference in a cohort that seemed inclined to quit anyway doesn't really give much confidence in even the thoughts of the subjects:
 
{{quote2|57.1% of those smoking from branded packs were "seriously considering quitting in the next 6 months", whereas this rose to 68.8% for those smoking from plain packs.<ref>[http://velvetgloveironfist.blogspot.co.uk/2013/07/that-plain-packaging-study.html That plain packaging study ] - Velvet Glove, Iron Fist blog</ref> }}
 
{{quote2|57.1% of those smoking from branded packs were "seriously considering quitting in the next 6 months", whereas this rose to 68.8% for those smoking from plain packs.<ref>[http://velvetgloveironfist.blogspot.co.uk/2013/07/that-plain-packaging-study.html That plain packaging study ] - Velvet Glove, Iron Fist blog</ref> }}
 +
 +
Note, too, that no follow-up was every carried out. The authors of the report still don't know how many of those 57.1% (or, indeed 68.8%) actually gave up!
  
 
== Authors ==
 
== Authors ==

Revision as of 13:53, 23 July 2013

A rather one-sided review of the Australian [plain packaging] experiment entitled Introduction effects of the Australian plain packaging policy on adult smokers: a cross-sectional study, notoriously used as proof of success in since one of its conclusions was

(smokers on plain packs) were more likely to have thought about quitting at least once a day in the past week (AdjOR=1.81, p=0.013) and to rate quitting as a higher priority in their lives (F=13.11, df=1, p<0.001).

Clearly, the implication that everyone who thinks about quitting, actually does, is nonsense.

The fact that these numbers equate to a nigh-on 10% difference in a cohort that seemed inclined to quit anyway doesn't really give much confidence in even the thoughts of the subjects:

57.1% of those smoking from branded packs were "seriously considering quitting in the next 6 months", whereas this rose to 68.8% for those smoking from plain packs.[1]

Note, too, that no follow-up was every carried out. The authors of the report still don't know how many of those 57.1% (or, indeed 68.8%) actually gave up!

Authors

References

  1. That plain packaging study - Velvet Glove, Iron Fist blog